Looking to purchase a mailing list? Start here first!
Let’s get something out of the way upfront: “Purchasing a mailing list” isn’t exactly a sexy phrase. But if you want to grow your business using direct mail—and especially if you want to scale or introduce cold traffic into your pipeline—then the list you mail is the most important factor in your campaign’s success.
Not the copy. Not the design. Not even the incredible 3D Mail item we help you send.
In the direct mail world, there’s a timeless truth we all live by:
40% of your success is the list
40% is the offer
20% is the creative
If you purchase the wrong mailing list, even the best offer and copy on the planet won’t save you. You could have Dan Kennedy writing your letter, Gary Halbert crafting the headline, and the world’s most irresistible offer… but if your piece ends up in the wrong mailbox, it’s all a waste.
That’s why savvy marketers don’t just “buy a list.” They invest in a strategic list—one that’s matched to their ideal prospect profile and buying behavior.
You’ve probably heard the horror stories. You send a mailer to 1,000 supposed “licensed attorneys” only to get 50 returned envelopes, 30 angry phone calls from people who haven’t practiced law in a decade, and one livid spouse whose husband passed away three years ago.
You get what you pay for. Those cheap $49 online lists might look tempting—but they’re often compiled from outdated or unverified sources. If you value your reputation, your postage budget, and your sanity, steer clear.
Let’s walk through what’s actually available when you decide to purchase a mailing list:
This is the most valuable list you own. These are your current and past customers. If you’re not marketing to them regularly—stop everything and start. If you’ve got a good CRM, segment them by buying behavior, LCV, or product interest. Make different offers to different segments. It’s one of the fastest ways to boost response and profitability.
These are people who’ve responded to an offer in your niche. Think: people who bought from Omaha Steaks, called about a Sun-Setter awning, or requested a free report on reverse mortgages. They’ve raised their hand and taken some action. These lists typically perform very well when you can find a close match to your audience.
These are put together using public records, warranty card data, surveys, credit info, and more. While you don’t know for sure if they’re buyers, you do get demographic and psychographic data: income, age, home value, marital status, etc. For local and geographic targeting, they can be a gold mine—if sourced correctly.
Want the safest play in compiled data? Stick with the major players: Acxiom, Experian, Excelsior, and Dunn & Bradstreet (for B2B). And yes—we’re an authorized list broker with D&B, so we’ve got you covered.
Is it a response or compiled list?
When was it last updated or “cleaned”?
Is there a deliverability guarantee? (91% is the industry standard for consumer, 88% for business)
What’s the minimum order size?
Is this a one-time rental or do I get multiple uses?
Are there seeds or traps embedded to track unauthorized use?
Can I segment the data based on geography, income, past buying behavior, etc.?
If your provider can’t answer those questions confidently, walk away.
I always say: Your message to market match is your biggest leverage point. And your mailing list is the market. When you purchase a mailing list, you’re not just buying names and addresses. You’re buying access to buyers—people who’ve shown interest in something you sell, or meet the exact profile of your ideal client.
Mailing to a broad, generic list is like throwing spaghetti at the wall. But mailing to a targeted, segmented, verified list? That’s laser-guided marketing—and it’s how you scale.
Ready to Mail Smarter, Not Harder? Don’t gamble with outdated, overpriced, or underperforming lists. Let us help you purchase the right mailing list—response-driven, laser-targeted, and built to convert.
📞 Call us today at 888-250-1834
📩 Or email info@3dmailresults.com to get started.
We’ll help you find your ideal audience—and deliver mail that actually gets opened, read, and acted on.
(888) 250-1834
Add Your Comments